Murphys weighs strengths, weaknesses

By Krissi Krob
Calaveras Enterprise
Posted: Friday, May 25, 2007 10:15 AM CDT

 

More than 80 Murphys area residents gathered at the Native Sons Hall Tuesday night to discuss the general plan update, despite having less than a week's notice that the workshop was taking place.

"This is a fantastic turnout in spite of our failure to get out notice ahead of time," said Stephanie Moreno, Community Development Agency director. "I want to encourage you all to stay a part of this process relative to the general plan ... We will be having public discussions - a lot of them - this year, and I'd like you to stay involved."

General plan update workshops are scheduled for June 12 in
Arnold and June 13 in Rail Road Flat, and one is tentatively scheduled for June 21 in Valley Springs.

Tom Tryon, county supervisor, was present at the meeting as well, and participated during the question and answer portion of a general plan presentation by Larry Mintier, of the Sacramento consulting firm Mintier and Associates, to address concerns raised by members of the audience. He emphasized that Tuesday's meeting was about the general plan update, not about updating Murphys' community plan.

"I am a very strong advocate of not including community plans in the general plan process," he said. "The reason is the general plan update is going to be nightmarish enough as it is, and to include all the community plans ... it will just get longer and more convoluted and, quite frankly, the Murphys community plan and the Murphys community will get lost in the general plan process."

"All a community plan is, really, is a number of paragraphs that end up in the document that talk about the specific and special things in your community that you want to be a little bit different in the overall plan," Moreno added.

 

At each table in the room was a map of Calaveras County, with a close up of the Murphys area - although the room was so crowded that some tables had to use maps with Copperopolis inserts. After the general plan presentation, each table was asked to brainstorm for 30 minutes and make a list of assets and problems in Murphys and Calaveras County.

Participants were asked to name the top three assets in the Murphys community and the top three community problems, then to do the same for
Calaveras County. Some audience members were concerned the exercise would give the impression that there were only three assets/problems in Murphys, but were assured that Mintier would take all concerns into consideration.

Overall, participants said they thought Murphys' assets include its historic significance, charming ambience,
Feeney Park, low noise level, the number of locally owned businesses and the absence of franchises, and community involvement in town activities, such as Irish Days. Countywide, Murphys residents said assets include its natural beauty, rural character, per capita income, tourist attractions, beautiful state parks, the absence of "big-box" retailers, wineries and the county's high level of volunteerism.

 

When it came to problems needing to be addressed, Murphys traffic problems, lack of adequate parking, water and sewer infrastructure (some thought it may be inadequate for future development) and road conditions were named. In the county, affordable housing, population pressure, jobs, traffic, and public transportation were all recognized as problems that need to be solved.

"We're going to be taking all this input and using it as the early outreach foundation for the rest of the general plan update," Mintier said. "So this is a very important meeting in terms of us getting a sense of what's on people's minds before we get too far along in this general plan update program."

Several audience members addressed concerns that the public had not been notified far enough in advance of the meeting, and were hopeful that something could be done to let residents know sooner when future meetings would take place. Michal Houston, president of the Murphys Community Club, said the club would serve to "keep the community informed in a timely fashion" of any general plan update workshops taking place.

"I think it's a great turnout," Tryon said. "It's the largest turnout I've ever seen for a general plan or even a community plan issue ... Hopefully, we'll have a good process and it won't be so contentious that it gets reduced to lawsuits."

Judy Ospital, who has lived in Murphys for 28 years, said she went to the workshop "to be here in the beginning" of the general plan update. She was impressed with the turnout, and credited it to the unique mix of people living in Murphys, including an active senior citizen population.

Throughout the meeting, Mintier,
Moreno, and Tryon assured audience members that public participation would remain an integral part of the update process.

 

"We will have three more rounds similar to this," Mintier said. "As we move through the process you'll have more and more information that we're preparing to present to you for your reaction."

Contact Krissi Krob at kkrob@calaverasenterprise.com.